|
|
Friday, September 07, 2007
Link-O-RamaSouhan spent this week hiding behind an anonymous second-hand source to irresponsibly accuse Joe Mauer of making up an injury, when anyone with five minutes and access to Google knows that wasn't the case. Meanwhile, Hartman used his prime newspaper real estate to suggest that "Ron Gardenhire should be named American League Manager of the Year" because "it's amazing they were able to hang in there as long as they did given the number of injuries they've had this year." Right. Jack has been given that opportunity and he's a player we've always liked. When Chavy went down we thought, who are we going to get to play third base, and we thought, let's give this kid a chance. We wanted to draft him years ago. ... We've been looking for that kind of power and on-base in the middle of the lineup for a few years. Jack certainly has a long-term future here.Of course, no matter what he does with the A's I'll always remember Hannahan most for starring in the greatest basketball game that I've ever witnessed in person. As always, comments about how I have the musical taste of a 17-year-old girl are encouraged. Once you're done here, check out my latest "Daily Dose" column over at Rotoworld.
Thursday, September 06, 2007
The Pay Off: Part 2 (Jason Bartlett and Jason Kubel)As discussed in this space Tuesday, Scott Baker has become a prime example of the truism that for the most part young players with strong minor-league track records eventually develop into good major-league players. Baker was heavily criticized and labeled as a bust following a poor performance last season, but given some patience and another chance to prove himself this year he's grabbed hold of a spot in the rotation by simply pitching like his track record suggested that he could all along. Baker is at a stage in his development that's similar to where Jason Bartlett was at this point last year. Whereas Baker posted a 6.37 ERA in 2006 and then began this season back at Triple-A in favor of Ramon Ortiz and Sidney Ponson, Bartlett hit .241/.316/.335 in 2005 and began last season back at Triple-A in favor of Juan Castro. After struggling in his first chance to claim the starting shortstop job, Bartlett got tons of criticism and little patience, much like Baker. Then, like Baker did earlier this season, Bartlett performed well following his demotion to Triple-A and thrived when given another chance in Minnesota. Called up last June when the Twins finally decided to ditch Castro, Bartlett started each of the season's final 99 games while hitting .309/.367/.393 with 10 steals. However, just as Baker went through a rough patch upon rejoining the rotation early this year, Bartlett began this season with one hit in his first 20 at-bats. Bartlett's slow start at the plate and some early problems defensively led to the return of frequent criticism, but he's fortunately turned things around and has been one of the team's few bright spots offensively. Bartlett has hit .275/.346/.380 with 21 steals in 121 games overall, including .285/.356/.396 with 20 steals in 23 attempts during the 114 games since snapping the season-opening slump. Add it all up and he's hit .290/.355/.386 in 220 games since getting a second chance and replacing Castro. MLB shortstops have hit .275/.330/.407 over the past two years, so Bartlett's .290/.355/.386 hitting line puts him solidly above average. According to Value Over Replacement Player, which compares hitters to other players at their position, his offense has been worth 18.3 runs more than a replacement-level shortstop this season. That ranks fourth on the Twins--behind only Torii Hunter (36.8), Justin Morneau (34.2), and Joe Mauer (28.0)--and ranks 13th among all big-league shortstopsMuch like Baker's good pitching, Bartlett's good hitting matches up with his minor-league track record. Held back by the Twins far past the point when he had something to prove at Triple-A, Bartlett batted .323/.388/.458 in 186 games spread over three seasons at Rochester. He failed to thrive immediately in the majors, and as is often the case that made people forget that for the most part young players with strong minor-league track records eventually develop into good major-league players. With two strong seasons now under his belt, Bartlett has officially cleared the hurdle to become a "good major-league player." Baker is about a year or so behind Bartlett, which means that he's in the process of getting over that same hump. Jason Kubel hasn't gotten past the "disappointment and criticism" stage of his development, but a closer look at his season shows a young player who appears to be setting himself up to follow the same path as Baker and Bartlett. After missing the entire 2005 season following a career-threatening knee injury, Kubel came back last year and hit just .241/.279/.386 in 73 games. He showed some flashes of potential in limited playing time during the first half, but fell apart physically after the All-Star break, batting just .163 while often struggling to simply get down the first-base line. Given another chance this season, Kubel got off to a slow start by batting just .237/.287/.301 through early May. Kubel broke a 0-for-11 slump by going 2-for-3 with a double on May 10 and has been one of the Twins' best hitters since then, batting .275/.338/.471 with 10 homers and 18 doubles in 79 games. Despite getting inconsistent playing time thanks to Ron Gardenhire often benching Kubel in favor of guys like Rondell White, Lew Ford, and Jason Tyner, among Twins hitters only Morneau (.517) and Hunter (.499) have a higher slugging percentage over that stretch. In addition to the excellent power, Kubel has also posted a solid batting average while improving his plate discipline and strike-zone control. He's drawn 26 walks in 285 plate appearances since May 10 after totaling 24 free passes through the first 403 plate appearances of his career, and he's done so while cutting his strikeouts by 20 percent. Even with his slow start thrown into the mix, among Twins hitters Kubel ranks fourth in slugging percentage (.425) and fifth in OPS (.750).Kubel's turnaround has largely flown under the radar, but that doesn't mean that it should come as a surprise. He's a career .320/.385/.499 hitter in 448 minor-league games, including .328/.384/.538 with 20 homers and 35 doubles in 120 games at Triple-A. Just like Baker, Bartlett, and any number of guys before him, Kubel looks likely to become another example that for the most part young players with strong minor-league track records eventually develop into good major-league players. The Twins have disappointed and frustrated this year, but the development of Baker, Bartlett, and Kubel are bright spots in an otherwise forgettable season. The paths they've taken show that early struggles are far from the end of the world for young players with strong minor-league track records, which is an extremely important lesson and one that will hopefully be applied to Kevin Slowey, Alexi Casilla, and the next wave of young talent. Once you're done here, check out my latest "Daily Dose" column over at Rotoworld.
Tuesday, September 04, 2007
The Pay Off: Part 1 (Scott Baker)There have been and will be exceptions, of course, but for the most part young players with strong minor-league track records eventually develop into good major-league players. Among baseball's many truisms, that point is perhaps one of the most basic and important. In fact, if I wrote up a list of principles or beliefs that drive my analysis of baseball--which sounds like a potential project for a very slow day this offseason--that would be near the top. Despite that, the truism often gets overlooked and forgotten, at least initially, because the payoff doesn't always come immediately. For example, Jack Cust was a first-round pick in 1997 and put up big numbers in the minors for a decade, hitting .286/.429/.518 with 200 homers and 924 walks in 1,114 games. His minor-league track record was beyond strong, yet Cust bounced around constantly as property of the Diamondbacks, Rockies, Orioles, A's, and Padres. Cust saw a grand total of 169 plate appearances in the majors through the age of 27, with no more than 85 coming in one place. He batted just .222 in those various brief stints as a big leaguer spread over parts of five seasons, and was written off by many as a so-called "Quadruple-A player." That label gets tossed around often when someone with a strong track record in the minors fails to immediately succeed in the majors and it's a label that might have stuck with Cust if not for this season. After batting .293/.467/.549 with 30 homers and 143 walks in 130 games for the Padres' Triple-A team last season, Cust remained at Portland to begin this year and hit .300/.430/.725 in 25 games. While jaw-dropping, those numbers fit with the rest of Cust's long minor-league track record. No doubt viewing the minor-league veteran as little more than Triple-A depth, the Padres happily traded Cust to the A's in May, receiving either a Player to be Named Later or cash considerations in the exchange. Given a chance for regular playing time in the majors for the first time since 2003, Cust homered in his A's debut, went deep a total of six times in his first week with the team, and hasn't looked back. Labeled as a Quadruple-A player and looked at as a bust just months ago, Cust has hit .266/.405/.536 with 23 homers and 77 walks in 101 games. No one, not even the A's, expected that type of production from Cust, but his .286/.429/.518 line in 1,114 minor-league games showed that it was possible. And why? Because for the most part young players with strong minor-league track records eventually develop into good major-league players. What does all of this have to do with the Twins? A lot, actually. On the most basic level, all of the success that the Twins have experienced over the past seven years has been built upon the development of young players. But for every Joe Mauer or Francisco Liriano who immediately makes a huge impact in the majors, there are multiple players who struggle initially.From Justin Morneau and Michael Cuddyer to Torii Hunter and Johan Santana, most of the team's best players struggled before establishing themselves in the majors. Both Hunter and Santana were demoted back to Triple-A despite having multiple big-league seasons under their belts, Morneau batted .239 in the year before he won the AL MVP, and Cuddyer needed over 1,000 plate appearances with the Twins before he began hitting like his minor-league track record suggested he could. None of which is to say that every young player should be given never-ending patience or an endless leash, because the key is the quality track record. Luis Rivas was young and got handed a starting job season after season, but there was nothing in his minor-league performance to suggest that he was capable of becoming a good major-league player. Sure enough, he batted .262/.307/.383 in six years with the Twins and has spent the past two seasons putting up mediocre numbers at Triple-A. However, when the young player has a strong minor-league track record patience is warranted when they don't immediately duplicate those numbers in the majors. Of course, that's a lot easier said than done. I tend to give the benefit of the doubt to young players when they come along with a promising track record, perhaps to the point of overvaluing potential and undervaluing experience. Most people seem to be at the opposite end of the spectrum, quickly souring on youth that struggles. A good example of that is Scott Baker, who moved quickly through the minors after being taken in the second round of the 2003 draft. After beginning his professional career with a 2.44 ERA and 156-to-27 strikeout-to-walk ratio in 166 innings between Single-A and Double-A, Baker posted a 3.57 ERA and 143-to-41 strikeout-to-walk ratio in 189 innings at Triple-A. That earned him a call-up to Minnesota in 2005, where he posted a 3.35 ERA in 53.2 innings with the Twins. A 23-year-old former second-round pick with a strong track record and rare success in his first taste of the majors, Baker's future looked bright however you sliced it. Then he began last season in the Twins' rotation and struggled, going 5-8 with a 6.37 ERA in 16 starts. Despite still being just 24 years old and posting a 2.67 ERA in a dozen starts at Triple-A following a demotion, many Twins fans soured on Baker almost immediately. Suddenly it was tough to find someone who had any faith in his ability to get big-league hitters out. He was an afterthought whenever the team's long-term rotation was discussed and frequently mentioned as someone who the Twins should be trying to trade. Rarely critical of anyone, FSN announcers Dick Bremer and Bert Blyleven seemingly made it their mission to play up Baker's struggles and focus on his weaknesses each time he took the mound. Baker began this season back at Rochester, where he once again performed very well with a 3.16 ERA and 41-to-4 strikeout-to-walk ratio in 42.2 innings alongside Kevin Slowey and Matt Garza in the Triple-A rotation. Called up in mid-May, Baker was fantastic against the Brewers in his first start, nearly tossing a complete game before settling for 8.1 innings of two-run ball. Following his impressive season debut, I wrote the following about Baker: Judging from the comments left here and the e-mails I've received on the subject, it's clear that Baker's performance last season convinced a huge percentage of Twins fans that he'll never be a good major-league pitcher. In fact, I'm not sure that I've ever seen a fan base turn so quickly and strongly on a young player based on one bad half season. I've been relatively steadfast in my support of Baker and, while it was just one game, Saturday's start against the Brewers showed why: Baker can pitch.Unfortunately, Baker struggled during his next four outings, at which point all patience seemed to disappear and the level of criticism intensified even further. In an effort to calm the amazingly negative reaction to his struggles, I compared Baker's first 30 big-league starts to a handful of successful Twins pitchers who also struggled through that early stage of their careers. When the level of criticism being thrown at Baker grew even stronger, I wrote: The amazingly negative reaction he gets from many Twins fans has sort of forced me into a position of defending him to some degree. ... He now has a 5.14 ERA and 129-to-41 strikeout-to-walk ratio in 184 career innings, which are the type of numbers that bode well for the future of a 25-year-old pitcher with an outstanding minor-league track record. For whatever reason many fans seemingly view him as a worthless bum, but he clearly doesn't deserve that level of vitriol. He deserves some patience.That was written on July 2. It's just two months later, but you'll be hard-pressed to find anyone willing to call him a bum or a Quadruple-A pitcher now, because all of those fans who made a habit of ripping Baker have seemingly disappeared. Suddenly the talking points put forth by Bremer and Blyleven don't sound like they've been put together by some sort of anti-Baker political campaign, and he's once again viewed as a prominent part of the team's future. Why the sudden, dramatic change in the public's perception of Baker? Because after a couple dozen rough starts early in his career, a 25-year-old former second-round pick with a strong minor-league track record and initial big-league success has begun consistently pitching well in the majors. In other words, for the most part young players with strong minor-league track records eventually develop into good major-league players. Baker took a perfect game into the ninth inning Friday against the Royals and had a no-hitter with two outs remaining before Mike Sweeney's bloop single ruined history. He settled for his first career complete-game shutout, and since comparing Baker's sub par numbers through 30 career starts to other Twins pitchers through the same point in their careers, he's gone 7-4 with 3.16 ERA and 65-to-16 strikeout-to-walk ratio in 94 innings spread over 14 starts.Baker now has a 4.67 ERA and 179-to-55 strikeout-to-walk ratio in 258 career innings, which are the type of numbers that you'd expect him to turn in given his minor-league track record and the type of performance that makes a 25-year-old pitcher a long-term building block. You've now read it enough to know it, so say it with me: For the most part young players with strong minor-league track records eventually develop into good major-league players. And as was always the case, Baker can pitch. Once you're done here, check out my latest "Daily Dose" column over at Rotoworld.
|
E-Mail: aarongleeman@gmail.com Twitter: twitter.com/aarongleeman Read Me Elsewhere Rotoworld NBC Sports MinnPost Minnesota Twins Stuff Minneapolis Star Tribune St. Paul Pioneer Press MinnesotaTwins.com LaVelle E. Neal III Joe Christensen Kelsie Smith Kelly Thesier Seth Stohs Stick and Ball Guy Nick Nelson Parker Hageman Phil Mackey John Bonnes Edward Thoma Josh Johnson Howard Sinker Twinkie Town Pat Neshek Sports Stuff Hardball Talk Rotoworld Fan Graphs Baseball-Reference.com The Hardball Times Baseball America Baseball Think Factory Bill Simmons Rob Neyer Joe Posnanski Big League Stew The Big Lead Deadspin Fanhouse Baseball Prospectus U.S.S. Mariner Al's Ramblings Sports By Brooks Baseball Musings MLB Trade Rumors Non-Sports Stuff MinnPost Alan Sepinwall David Brauer Adam Carolla Poker Road Gorilla Mask Wicked Chops Poker WWTDD? Popoholic The Superficial Steve Silver Tao of Poker Discount Sporting Goods ![]() Official Fantasy Girl of AG.com OFGoAG.com Timeline: Heidi Klum (8/2002 - 12/2003) Jessica Alba (12/2003 - 10/2004) Elisha Cuthbert (10/2004 - 11/2006) Vacant (11/2006 - 6/2008) Keeley Hazell (6/2008 - 3/2010) Mila Kunis (3/2010 - Present) OFGoAG.com Candidates: Marisa Miller Jenna Fischer Kate Beckinsale Keeley Hazell Diora Baird Top 40 Twins Prospects of 2010: 1. Aaron Hicks, CF 2. Kyle Gibson, SP 3. Wilson Ramos, C 4. Miguel Angel Sano, SS 5. Ben Revere, CF 6. Angel Morales, CF 7. David Bromberg, SP 8. Danny Valencia, 3B 9. Matthew Bashore, SP 10. Billy Bullock, RP 11. Rene Tosoni, RF 12. Chris Parmelee, RF 13. Adrian Salcedo, SP 14. Joe Benson, CF 15. Jeff Manship, SP 16. Tyler Robertson, SP 17. Carlos Gutierrez, RP 18. B.J. Hermsen, SP 19. Anthony Slama, RP 20. Max Kepler, CF 21. Alex Burnett, RP 22. Robert Delaney, RP 23. Luke Hughes, 3B 24. Ben Tootle, RP 25. Deolis Guerra, SP 26. Shooter Hunt, SP 27. Trevor Plouffe, SS 28. Michael McCardell, SP 29. Reggie Williams, 2B 30. Estarlin De Los Santos, SS 31. Derek McCallum, 2B 32. Jose Morales, C 33. Chris Herrmann, LF 34. Bobby Lanigan, SP 35. Danny Rams, C 36. Josmil Pinto, C 37. Steven Tolleson, 2B 38. Anderson Hidalgo, 3B 39. Loek Van Mil, RP 40. Joe Testa, RP |